A haunted history podcast · Maine to Key West

Route 1
Unknown

Route 1 is longer than you think.

Haunted history and true crime along U.S. Route 1, from the Canadian border in Maine to Key West. Every episode stops somewhere along the old road to ask what really happened there, and what we still can’t explain. New episodes every Monday.

Latest episode

All episodes
Moonlit sea off a rocky Block Island shore with a burning light on the horizon, cover art for The Palatine Light episode

Episode 5 · Block Island, Rhode Island · Nov 16, 2026

The Palatine Light

In 1738 an immigrant ship called the Princess Augusta reached Block Island, Rhode Island. Her passengers were Palatines, German-speaking emigrants bound for Philadelphia, and the voyage had already killed most of the people aboard, around four out of every five. The captain, George Long, was among the dead. His first mate, Andrew Brook, took command, and the record of what he did next is the darkest part of this story: he led the exploitation and abandonment of the surviving passengers.

Next stop, Monday Nov 23: Moll Dyer, Leonardtown, Maryland.

Listen wherever you drive

Recent case files

All episodes

Fact, folklore, or something else

The record

Court transcripts, newspapers, letters and archives. What can be shown, we show, and we say where it came from.

The witnesses

The people who were there, and the people who kept telling it. Their accounts are evidence of something, even when they can’t be proven.

The legend

The parts no one can confirm and no one can let go. We tell them as legend, never as fact, and ask why they survive.