The case files

Episodes

Each stop on the road, with what the record shows, what the witnesses said, and what remains unexplained. New episodes of this haunted history podcast arrive every Monday on Spotify and Apple Podcasts.

Moonlit sea off a rocky Block Island shore with a burning light on the horizon, cover art for The Palatine Light episode

Episode 5 · Block Island, Rhode Island · Nov 16, 2026

The Palatine Light

In 1738 an immigrant ship called the Princess Augusta reached Block Island, Rhode Island. Her passengers were Palatines, German-speaking emigrants bound for Philadelphia, and the voyage had already killed most of the people aboard, around four out of every five. The captain, George Long, was among the dead. His first mate, Andrew Brook, took command, and the record of what he did next is the darkest part of this story: he led the exploitation and abandonment of the surviving passengers.

Two survivors stayed on the island. Islanders remembered them as “Long Kate” and “Short Kate.”

More than a century later, John Greenleaf Whittier turned the story into a poem called “The Palatine.” And for generations, people on Block Island have described a burning light out on the water: the Palatine Light.

In this episode we separate the record from the legend. We look at what the oldest written sources say, including Willey (around 1811) and Samuel Adams Drake (1884), at what Whittier’s poem added, and at why New England’s most famous ghost ship keeps appearing off the Rhode Island coast. It is a shipwreck story, a piece of maritime folklore and a haunted history mystery in one, a ferry ride from Route 1 in southern Rhode Island.

Lamp-lit cobblestone street in old New York at night leading to ships at the docks, Route 1 Unknown cover art for Judge Lansing

Episode 4 · New York City · Nov 9, 2026 · 44 min

The Disappearance of Judge Lansing

On December 12, 1829, a seventy-five-year-old man walked out of a hotel on Broadway in New York City to mail letters at the Cortlandt Street docks. He never came back. No body was ever found, and no witness ever came forward.

His name was John Lansing Jr. In 1787 he walked out of the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia rather than sign on to a government he believed was too powerful. He went on to serve as Chief Justice and then Chancellor of New York. And in 1800 he presided over the Manhattan Well murder trial, where Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr sat at the same defense table.

This episode follows Lansing from Albany to Philadelphia to the bench, through that trial and the curse that was said to follow it, and into the search that began when he failed to come home. We set out the three main theories about what happened to him, look at what remains of the record, and say plainly where the evidence ends.

It is part two of our Manhattan pair: a true crime mystery and missing person case that is almost two hundred years old and still unsolved. If you haven’t heard it yet, start with The Manhattan Well Murder.

Old stone well at night in early New York, Route 1 Unknown cover art for The Manhattan Well Murder

Episode 3 · New York City · Nov 2, 2026 · 41 min

The Manhattan Well Murder

Beneath a clothing store in SoHo, under a glass panel in the floor, there is a stone well. In January 1800 the body of a twenty-two-year-old woman named Elma Sands was pulled out of it. On the night of December 22, 1799, she had told her cousin she was going out to marry Levi Weeks, a carpenter who boarded in the same Greenwich Street house. She never came back.

Weeks was charged with murder. His defense team included Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr, bitter rivals sitting at the same table. The trial ran through the night, and the jury took only minutes to acquit. According to accounts that circulated for decades, Elma’s cousin Catherine Ring stood up after the verdict and cursed the men who had freed him.

Within four years Hamilton was dead, shot by Burr at Weehawken. Within thirty, the judge who presided over the trial walked out of a hotel on Broadway one December evening and was never seen again. No one was ever convicted of Elma’s death. The well is still there.

This true crime podcast episode is part one of a Manhattan pair, drawing on William Coleman’s 1800 report of the trial and Paul Collins’s Duel with the Devil. Lower Manhattan was the end of the old Boston Post Road, the colonial route U.S. Route 1 later followed through much of New England, though modern Route 1 itself does not run through lower Manhattan.

Dark pine forest on the Chesapeake Bay at night, Route 1 Unknown cover art for Old House Woods

Episode 2 · Mathews County, Virginia · Oct 28, 2026 · 44 min

Old House Woods

A motorist on a fog-lined road in Mathews County, Virginia, stopped for an armored figure in his headlights. The figure asked him a question: “Is this the King’s highway? I’ve lost my ship.”

Old House Woods is about fifty acres of pine forest on the shore of the Chesapeake Bay. For roughly three hundred years, the people who live near it have described the same things: a ship with lit lanterns sailing above the trees, skeleton soldiers in armor carrying lanterns and chests, lights that follow travelers home, and a woman in white who screams before a storm.

Local tradition offers three competing legends, and each one is tied to buried treasure. None can be verified. None will go away.

In this episode we line up the witnesses of Mathews County, test what the natural explanations can account for, and look honestly at what they miss. It is one of Virginia’s best-known ghost stories and a classic piece of Chesapeake Bay folklore, out on the Middle Peninsula east of the Route 1 corridor. It was released as the second half of our Halloween pair, alongside The Last Vampire of New England.

Frosted New England graveyard under a full moon, Route 1 Unknown cover art for The Last Vampire of New England

Episode 1 · Exeter, Rhode Island · Oct 28, 2026 · 38 min

The Last Vampire of New England

In 1892, the same decade as the first automobiles, the people of Exeter, Rhode Island opened the grave of a nineteen-year-old woman named Mercy Lena Brown. Tuberculosis, then called consumption, had already taken her mother, Mary Eliza, in 1883 and her sister Mary Olive in 1888. Mercy died in January 1892. Now her brother Edwin was wasting away, and some of the neighbors believed one of the dead was feeding on the living.

On March 17, 1892, a group of men exhumed the Brown family graves in the Chestnut Hill Baptist Church cemetery. They cut out Mercy’s heart, burned it on a rock, and fed the ashes to Edwin. He died anyway. A doctor who examined the body said the ritual was nonsense, and he was overruled.

This haunted history episode follows the last documented American vampire exhumation, from the terror of consumption and George Brown’s losses to the newspaper storm that followed. Five years later Bram Stoker published Dracula, and a clipping about Mercy Brown turned up among his research papers.

It is a true story about grief, fear and a farming town a short drive inland from U.S. Route 1, and about the family it destroyed. It was the first episode of Route 1 Unknown, released Oct 28, 2026.