Episode 5 · Block Island, Rhode Island · Nov 16, 2026
The Palatine Light
In 1738 an immigrant ship called the Princess Augusta reached Block Island, Rhode Island. Her passengers were Palatines, German-speaking emigrants bound for Philadelphia, and the voyage had already killed most of the people aboard, around four out of every five. The captain, George Long, was among the dead. His first mate, Andrew Brook, took command, and the record of what he did next is the darkest part of this story: he led the exploitation and abandonment of the surviving passengers.
Two survivors stayed on the island. Islanders remembered them as “Long Kate” and “Short Kate.”
More than a century later, John Greenleaf Whittier turned the story into a poem called “The Palatine.” And for generations, people on Block Island have described a burning light out on the water: the Palatine Light.
In this episode we separate the record from the legend. We look at what the oldest written sources say, including Willey (around 1811) and Samuel Adams Drake (1884), at what Whittier’s poem added, and at why New England’s most famous ghost ship keeps appearing off the Rhode Island coast. It is a shipwreck story, a piece of maritime folklore and a haunted history mystery in one, a ferry ride from Route 1 in southern Rhode Island.